Readers and editors · 5 of 14
Reviewing your editor’s pass
3 min read · checked Oct 30, 2026
An editor or copyeditor works on their own copy of a sealed draft. When they are done, they submit the pass to you. Nothing they changed is in your book yet. You go through their changes one by one, keep the ones you want, and turn down the rest.
Where the pass shows up
Pass on the right-hand rail is the editor’s pass. Before anything comes back, opening it tells you whether an editor is at work, who, and on what kind of pass. If no editor has your book, it says so and offers Invite an editor.
Once a pass has come back, selecting Pass switches your chapter to the redline and opens the panel beside it. The panel shows a summary of what the editor returned: mechanical fixes, rephrasings and queries, counted when they submitted it. Their letter to you sits under the counts.
Seeing the changes on the page
In the redline, deletions are struck through, insertions are highlighted, and the editor’s comments appear as small badges you can click. The Editor’s suggestions switch in the panel turns these marks on and off.
Only one set of marks shows at a time, so turning on the editor’s suggestions puts your readers’ notes away. Select Pass on the rail again to go back to your clean page.
Deciding on a change
- Click any highlighted change. Small controls appear right above it.
- Choose Accept to keep it, or Reject to leave your words as they were.
- A rejected change offers Accept instead, if you change your mind.
An accepted change is applied to your chapter straight away, and is marked as kept. It cannot be taken back from the redline, because the editor sees your decisions too. If you need to undo it, edit the text yourself.
A line on the page counts the changes still to decide in this chapter. The panel shows the same as a progress bar, and says when every change has been decided.
Your earlier version is kept
Accepting your first change in a chapter creates a new version of that chapter, v2. The version the editor reviewed stays exactly as it was and remains readable, so you can always see what they worked from. Later accepts in the same pass go into that same new version. Only chapters where you accept something get a new version.
If you open an older version, the panel tells you it is historical and cannot be edited. Open the latest one to keep writing.
Answering the editor’s questions
Click a comment badge on the page to open the conversation. Each message is a bubble, yours on one side and the editor’s on the other. Type a reply and send it, or press Cmd and Return. Either of you can keep the exchange going.
Editors give each question a category, such as Fact-check, Pacing, Style, Continuity or Grammar, so you can tell a quick check from a structural worry.
Co-authors can decide too
A co-author sees the same redline you do and can accept and reject changes. The editor only ever proposes.
Read the editor’s letter before the first change. It usually explains the thinking behind dozens of small edits, and makes each decision quicker.